People tell me we live in a flat-structured, leadership-cultured,
life-balanced world – but do we really? Lately
I've been wondering about the managers and leaders
I meet:
- why
so many are dissatisfied with themselves and their
work
- why
so many of them blame the system or other people for
their own actions
- why
so many are very clear about what could make their
working life easier, but don't do anything about it
You know the symptoms don't you? They turn up late
for meetings. They prevaricate but then expect you to
be available at a moment's notice. They're never available
on the phone and don't answer emails. They drop out
of things at the last minute. They seem to be in perpetual
motion, ever busy, never ready. And their success often
falls far below their apparent level of effort. Yet
it's never their fault!
Many managers dig this rut for themselves by deciding
to let others dictate what they do at all times. I've
done a bit of research recently on reasons people give
for dropping out of development programmes they had
clearly found interesting and potentially beneficial.
The top three are:
- 'pressure
of work',
-
'three line whips'
-
'paper needed by Monday'
I've also noted that others from the same organisations
or departments, with the same bosses and same demands,
did attend.
What's going on then?
Recent research suggests that managers have surprisingly
little awareness of what they do at work. They wrongly
estimate the time they spend there and how they allocate
that time. For example:
- they
complain about telephone calls but spend only about
6% of their time on the phone
-
they say they have no controllable time but in fact
spend up to half their time in their own office
- they
say they are constantly called out to meetings –
but the big majority of meetings are pre-scheduled
-
research says that stand-up meetings are 34% shorter
with far greater satisfaction and no loss of quality
in the decisions but few use them
- they
say "that's the price of moving up" –
but senior managers do not work longer hours than
junior ones: the junior ones just get more stressed
So, being brave enough to take control of meetings
and learn the discipline to plan and say 'no' appropriately
are useful and would work.
They're not easy of course, because other research
shows that most managers dislike changing their patterns
of activity. This results in high attention to immediate,
known tasks and low attention to strategic organisational
or personal goals (because they might challenge why
the tasks are being done and suggest a change of habit).
This suggests that how managers use their time is an
organisational problem and any organisation needing
to make better use of its management potential can usefully:
- look
at how it can better encourage reflective learning
- make
it 'OK' for managers to disengage from immediate tasks
-
focus energy and attention on organisational priorities
But if managers feel as disempowered as they seem then
to challenge the status quo, to take greater ownership
for their own actions, they need to develop a stronger
sense of self. They need a clarity about 'who I am'
at work and a sense that they can legitimately influence
their own fate.
To develop this sense, managers can:
- learn
how others handle problems - perhaps through learning
sets or mentoring
- actively
seek out good quality feedback
-
reflect on their own management practice, for example
through a diary or coaching
In order to challenge the prevailing culture, managers
at all levels need to make this 'OK' for each other
by:
- acting
as highly effective role models within the organisation
- following
and encouraging others to follow properly structured
training and development
- the
relentless provision of skilful, constructive feedback
- developing
skills in self-awareness and learning to learn
Some particular research over recent years has shown
that many people live in a kind of state of 'waking
sleep' – they move through routine patterns of
behaviour but without full awareness of what they are
doing.
Have you ever got to the end of your day and wondered
what you have been doing? Then you've been sleeping
wakefully. In some areas of psychology this would be
called a trance – this may sound over the top
but we all exist like this some of the time.
Unfortunately being in a trance means that I am quite
literally 'not all there' because only my body is present.
So people don't feel I engage fully with them. I make
statements and promises that I don't remember afterwards.
The way to deal with this is to practise 'waking up'
– bringing the attention fully into the present
and experiencing each action, decision or person fully
and decisively.
This a consistent finding in business and psychology
research –- a 'present orientation' is associated
with greater managerial success and personal well-being.
Interestingly, it is also an ancient theme in both Christianity
and Buddhism.
I can only conclude that there is something in it!
|